Thursday, September 18, 2014

Scrum, and the Not Goodness Thereof

I do not have a huge amount of experience with the programming project management system known as Scrum, but what I have was not pleasant. Nor do I know any programmers that have found it pleasant, but again, minimal sample size there. It turns out I am not the only one who finds the process silly, and one of those other people wrote a post that perfectly captures what I have experienced:
"In [Giles Bowkett's] words, in it's best case scenario, Scrum's a dog-and-pony show. But that best case scenario is rare. In the much more common case, Scrum covers up the inability to recruit (or even recognize) engineering talent, which is currently one of the most valuable things in the world, with a process for managing engineers as if they were cogs in a machine, all of equal value."
I'm sure there are places out there using Scrum successfully, but I have never seen them. It seems to be a methodology using the trappings of Agile to hide that it actually comes from the fake world of scientific management. In that world, to achieve improvement, you must have The Metrics. The Metrics govern all processes. It doesn't matter if something is actually understood, it only matters that it is being Measured, and that the Measurement be Tracked.

Hmm. This turned into a bit of a rant post, so I need to look at what I can offer as a solution. In my (again, limited) experience, you get the best results when you trust your people. Of course you can't do it blindly. There must be accountability if something or someone fails to deliver, and management must be aware of and take into account individuals' interactions with other and their own desired goals. It certainly isn't the easiest path, but boy can it go gangbusters when it works. And if your team isn't capable of functioning smoothly together without a convoluted multi-process formal framework, then there are other fundamental issues that need to be solved. Is it too big? Is there a poison person? Are they being mismanaged? Is the end goal of the project unclear or shifting?

More and better minds than me, like Mr. Bowkett and Mr. Eckle above, have pondered the workings of a successful teams and successful businesses. Many trees have been felled and electrons spent in sending forth their conclusions. Yet it remains a hard problem to tackle, and like all people (and software) problems, the solutions will be at least somewhat unique every time.

Sunday, September 14, 2014

True Detective and Philosophy

Post-apocalypse stories, at least those that use the theme as more than set dressing, fall along an axis. At one end lies the ultimately positive story of life continuing after a Bad Thing happened. At the other lies the last struggling survivors and they rail, ultimately futilely, against inevitable death. In other words, optimism vs. pessimism. In different other words, existentialism vs. nihilism. I suspect that where the popular culture of the times fall into those spectra can say something about people's outlook on the world.*

HBO's recent series True Detective is not, strictly speaking, post-apocalyptic. Rather, it is heavily Southern Gothic, with the themes of mystery, decay, and dissolution twining through the cinematography and writing like wysteria covering an old tree. It does contain elements of the apocalyptic though, especially in the "revelation" sense of the word, as the main characters see the nature of their world revealed to them. And since it also draws from the classic weird story "The King in Yellow", you would not be wrong if you guessed that the revelation is not an entirely pleasant one. Rust, one of those main characters, is a self-described pessimist, in the philosophical sense rather than the colloquial one, and so it is very clear where he falls in the spectra at the start of the show. Where his arc takes him, I will not reveal here.

If you are looking for some horror viewing this autumn, you can't do much better than True Detective. And for more, and better, discussion about the philosophy behind horror and some nuggets on why nihilism can exist in pop culture, I refer you to this week's Radio Lab podcast, entitled "In the Dust of This Planet", which got me started thinking along these lines.

* Now that I have written that, I suddenly realize that which pair of philosophical struggles you more identify with might also tell you something significant about your religious beliefs, or lack thereof. But that is another topic, for someone much more educated along those lines than myself.

Saturday, September 13, 2014

Bookworming: Footprints in the Sand

Footprints in the Sand, Mary Jane Clark, ***
I don't have much to say about this one. It's a pretty straightforward contemporary "cozy" style mystery. Takes about a hundred pages to really get rolling, but afterward moves at a quick pace. Mystery fans will be at home here.

Thursday, September 11, 2014

Quote of the Moment

"A rose in a corn field is a weed."
— Mark Stewart, from assignment 14 of PBS Digital Studios's The Art Assignment

I suspect this one is going to mess with me for a while.

Wednesday, September 10, 2014

Robotic Naval Shipping?

Ars ran this article about research into unmanned shipping. My question is this: which will take hold first, seafaring shipping drones, aerial shipping drones, or driverless cars? My guess would be drone ships, since they have less possibilities of interaction with the general public and would therefore be more subject to pure economic forces. They are all coming eventually, but I would also guess I won't live to see any of the above in wide use.

Monday, September 8, 2014

Harvard Business School vs. the Wealth Gap

An analysis of a survey conducted by Harvard Business School on its graduates that called America's wealth gap unsustainable gives the following advice: "Harvard called on corporate leaders to help solve America's wealth gap by working to buttress the kindergarten-12th-grade education system, skills-training programs, and transportation infrastructure, among other things." There is no indication whether the 'other things' might include paying said corporate leaders less and workers more, or any other steps that might actually directly address the problem.

Thursday, September 4, 2014

Bookworming: Revenant

Revenant, Kat Richardson, ***
Walking a line between the previous installment's thriller tendencies and the earlier mystery stories with a dash of travelogue thrown in, the latest book in the Greywalker series is solid, though not a return to the series high water mark. It draws heavily on characters and situations from the previous books in the series and certainly would not make a good entry point for new readers. The relationships among the characters takes the forefront this time around, and for my tastes are extremely well done. The plot wasn't exactly as solid, unfortunately. The climax in particular seemed rather arbitrary to me. Still an easy one to recommend for fans of the series.

Wednesday, August 27, 2014

A Story About Gun Control

Nine year old girl accidentally kills gun instructor...
What a horrible tragedy.
... with an uzi.
OK, there may have been some poor decision making involved. (article)

Safety tip for you parents of young kids: teach them how to shoot using things with shoulder stocks. Or that fire non-lethal rounds. Preferably both.